Gaming, Technology, and Gadget News, Reviews, and Previews.
  • Home
  • About TTB
  • Post Archive
  • Submissions / Contact
  • Gift Shop
  • Games That Time Forgot
  • Retro Computing Corner
  • Video Friday

The People Have Spoken: ‘Spore’ Is Ruined By Its Own DRM

Author: Rees | Date: September 8, 2008

Spore has received overwhelmingly negative reviews on Amazon due to its draconian DRM

Judging by the reviews on Amazon.com (120 and counting), the public reaction to EA and Will Wright’s hugely-anticipated epic Sim-everything game, Spore, has been overwhelmingly negative.

The huge majority of the complaints seem to be aimed at one particular aspect of the game – not the gameplay itself, but EA’s decision to include the SecuROM DRM (Digital Rights Management) system. The much-maligned system only allows the game to be installed 3 times, before requiring a phone call to EA to request an extra activation.

This essentially reduces the game to nothing more than a rental, which will be completely useless when EA eventually switch off the activation servers. The system also installs software which runs with super user privileges that cannot be deactivated, which is a huge security risk and may well enable worm and virus attacks against Spore users in the future.

Understandably, paying customers are furious that they are being treated like pirates and are making their voices heard. You could download it DRM-free from your favourite torrent site after all – it won’t even cost you a penny either.

Other Recent TTB Stories

  • Want Recon Armour? Play More Halo 3! [Updated]
  • WAIP?: The Simpsons, The Simpsons & Fight Night Round 3 Edition
  • Lips Wireless Mics to Get Solo Gig
  • Retro Computing Corner: Aww… Look At The Cute Kitty!
  • The Ultimate Atari Setup Circa 1983
Add to Google

15 Comments »

Comment by M
2008-09-08 15:52:01

I fear that last sentence might cause you trouble.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by otakucode
2008-09-08 16:16:44

No, the last sentence is what will cause EA trouble and should be their primary concern when baking up new piracy-prevention methods.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by SmellyGeekBoy
2008-09-08 16:23:01

I’m not encouraging people to pirate the game – far from it, as I’m in the software development industry myself. I’d just rather the retail version offered all the freedom and hassle-free installation as the pirated version.

Perhaps people should buy the disc and download it?

Reply to this comment
Comment by M
2008-09-09 08:32:31

I hear you, but EA are good at unleashing hellspawn minions at anything that has a chance of deteriorating their image if they can put their hands on something that looks legal. They live on it.

Reply to this comment
 
 
Comment by devolute
2008-09-08 16:35:06

@SmellyGeekBoy

Give EA your money PLUS the opportunity to sue you for stealing their stuff? That doesn’t sound like a very attractive option.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by DarkWolf
2008-09-08 17:52:38

I bought the game off Direct2Drive, got my install key and used it in a pirated version, I think it is the best of both worlds.

I get to pay money for a good game and not be treated like the pirate I wasn’t.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by Marcus
2008-09-08 18:00:17

Has anyone heard of any problems installing yet?

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by Rich Nixon
2008-09-08 18:04:39

@SmellyGeekBoy – that’s not going to solve anything. EA needs to receive the message that this type of DRM is unacceptable. The only way to let them know that is to impact them financially. I don’t even know why you would think that rewarding them monetarily would help to deliver this message. Think about it.

I am not going to buy or play Spore.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by Tigervamp
2008-09-08 19:07:36

The cost of purchasing a new PC which will be good enough to even run Spore properly is already pricing me out of the market.

Unfortunately, if people decide not to buy this game I can see it affecting the people at Maxis far more than it will affect a company as large as Electronic Arts.

EA can afford to take a loss with one of their games but Maxis might find it more difficult to bounce back from poor sales and the knock-on bad publicity the game will receive due to this incredible error in judgement.

Although, having said that, they do have Sims 3 up their sleeves so I’m sure they’ll do just fine.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by SmellyGeekBoy
2008-09-08 19:13:50

I think Spore looks great, but I’ll be waiting a while until I buy it, not only because of the system requirements* but the whole DRM fiasco too. No wonder I’ve stuck to console gaming ever since Half-Life 2 was released (remember the activation server issues on the first few days? Eugh.)

*Apparently there is a hack to allow Spore to run on the Mac Mini’s GMA 950 graphics chipset, though I imagine it runs like a pig.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by Benzodiazepine
2008-09-09 02:44:35

Yeah, it’s a good idea for not in a rush to buy it.
Let’s see what’s gonna happen next.

The game looks cool but with limited time installing…?
Hello..it’s a trial then, not a ready-to-sell product.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by calipip4
2008-09-11 05:10:14

Most people have the whole idea of Securom and the 3 activations wrong..It’s not just a simple DRM, it installs seperately to the game without your knowledge..if you un-install the game..you don’t un-install the SecuRom, which makes it a rootkit (malware), so if you don’t know this, you will think it’s gone coz it hides in hidden folders and in your Registry, not to mention what it does to AV’s by disabling them and the damage it does to some of the PC”s hardware. The other issue I have with this type of Draconian DRM is that when you can’t afford the internet anymore, you can no longer Play a Game you Paid for, and that is wrong..most games aren’t played over the Net so why do we have to be connected to it. There is a lot bigger picture than what we’re seeing here right now, this is only a baby step to the end plan. I will not buy anything that is put out by EA anymore, even though I would love to buy Sims2 Ikea, Sims2 Apartment Life and Spore but I just don’t trust EA or Sony.

Reply to this comment
 
Comment by Marius Stubberud Buertange
2008-09-15 15:57:27

If you guys want a new and better spore, please help participate by signing this petition: http://www.petitiononline.com/restorsp/petition.html And by all means, get your friends and families to sign too and then they can spread it even further. These petitions do tend to get things done.

Thanks in advance
Sincerely
Marius

Reply to this comment
 
Click here to cancel "reply".
Name (why not register?)
E-mail (not required, but fill it in if you want an avatar!)
Your Website (not required)
Your Comment
First time commenters:
There is no need to re-submit your comment if it doesn't appear immediately, as all comments on this site are moderated. Basic HTML, emoticons ("smileys") and links are allowed. To get your own avatar, please sign up at Gravatar.com. Thanks!

Trackback responses to this post

  • EA’s Overly Restrictive DRM Causes Mini Riots in Sporetopia | Ripten Video Game Blog
  • Spore: Mac Gaming Evolves | MacApper

Review: Tiger Woods 11 (Xbox 360)Review: Tiger Woods 11 (Xbox 360)

Tiger Woods has returned. Nothing much has happened in the real life of Tiger Woods since the... »

Review: Tournament of Legends (Wii)Review: Tournament of Legends (Wii)

To the best of my knowledge the Nintendo Wii isn't blessed with many fighting games. Off the top... »

R4 Flashcarts Now Officially Illegal In UKR4 Flashcarts Now Officially Illegal In UK

Yep, you heard me right. The R4 flashcart, that seemingly-innocent little bit of plastic and... »

Get Your Virtual Groove (Publicly) On With Japanese Virtual Lady Simulator “Love Plus”Get Your Virtual Groove (Publicly) On With Japanese Virtual Lady Simulator “Love Plus”

Not a lot of people know this, but in Japan you can actually buy a vitual girlfriend simulator... »

Retro Computing Corner: 25 Years Of The Commodore AmigaRetro Computing Corner: 25 Years Of The Commodore Amiga

Today is the 24th of July 2010, and that can only mean one thing - the 25th birthday of the... »

Video Friday: The “Half-Life That Could Have Been” EditionVideo Friday: The “Half-Life That Could Have Been” Edition

Here's some retro gaming gold - a very early trailer for the original Half-Life. This trailer... »

Review: Crackdown 2 (Xbox 360)Review: Crackdown 2 (Xbox 360)

Crackdown provided one of the biggest surprises in this generation of consoles. Going on the... »

Review: Demon’s Souls (PS3)Review: Demon’s Souls (PS3)

This is quite unlike any game I have ever played. I have played many action RPGs. I have also... »

Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360)Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360)

During my teenage years Green Day were one of my favourite bands, Dookie was one of my favourite... »

Review: Sherlock Holmes (Blu-ray)Review: Sherlock Holmes (Blu-ray)

I really like the Sherlock Holmes character. Forget Poirot, Columbo, and the chimney sweep who... »

Everything For Your Console

Console Accessories from ConsoleBUZZ! Console Accessories for DS, Wii and Xbox 360. Free shipping in the UK!

Recent Comments

  • Review: Petz Fantasy (DS)
    • Tigervamp: Hi, not sure if this will help but there's an 'Unlockables area' here http://petz.uk.ubi.com/ at the bottom left of the…
    • CousinJarna: This game, while a bit boring for anyone over the age of 12, is perfect for my 4-5yr old lil…
  • Halo 3's Mythic Map Pack Is Here, Download It On LIVE Now!
    • Sims_Doc: Halo 3 on USB , now that would be the day.
  • Review: True Blood - Season One (DVD)
    • Tigervamp: First, Sam didn't grunt and I didn't say he did. Tara grunted in her sleep. You should know this if…
    • DiMi: Your discussion of Sam and Tara is offensive. You don't understand race or racial politics, you don't understand the scene,…
  • A Tribute To The Atari ST
    • Retro Computing Corner: 25 Years Of The Commodore Amiga | Team Teabag! - Home of the Latest Gaming, Technology, and Gadget News, Reviews, and Previews.: [...] even had its own set of fanboys back in its day, constantly at war with owners of the far…
  • Review: My Boyfriend (DS)
    • lynnekemeis: i'm stuck. my "boyfriend" is the athlete and i'm at the point that i'm gonna play a match with him. helping him…
    • anonymous: for the pepople that stuck on getting in the band or the football team u have to wear a purle…
  • Portal: The Flash Version Maps Go 3D
    • me: WHERE DO YOU GET THE DA*N THINGS!!!???!!!!???:(
  • ZOMG Nerdgasm: Chu Chu Rocket Coming to XBLA, VC, PSN?
    • Francis: Oh my god... Years of my youth playing this... The memories live on forever... I sure hope it comes out UNCHANGED in PSN…
  • Review: Dance Party Club Hits + Dance Party Pop Hits (Wii)
    • anonymous: I prefer Just Dance play, I love it, I think is better than this one
  • Review: Wet (Xbox 360)
    • lukadelic19: it met to have old western movie look about it which is ok but it annoying how …
  • Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360)
    • Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360) | Team Teabag! – Home of … | Rauls Photos: [...] See the article here: Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360) | Team Teabag! – Home of … [...]
    • Review: Green Day Rock Band (Xbox 360) | Team Teabag! – Home of … | Game Addictor: [...] View full post on Google Alerts – xbox 360 [...]
  • Star Wars Force Unleashed Deluxe Lightsaber (Hasbro) - Review
    • sean: After finding out it didn't work, I decided to have a look inside to see what really made this lightsaber…
  • The World's Fastest Police Car: The Caparo T1-RRV
    • anonymous: well good it could have been a bagati vayron but it will do :]:]
  • Top 10 Wednesday: Top 10 Achievement Whoring Games
    • Kian: Assassins Creed 2 has very easy achievements. Easy 900+ Gamerscore on this game (also easy for 1000G)
  • Teabagging Accuracy in Halo 3, The Stats
    • Someone: I teabag right in the chest, you get much more accurate teabags like that.
  • E3: Square Enix Drops the Bomb, Final Fantasy XIII for the 360
    • Benjamin: I don't get what the big deal is about changing discs... it shocks me how lazy people can be xD
  • Bungie signs 10 year deal with Activision - How long will the honeymoon last?
    • Halo fan 360.: I know that Halo:3 and Halo;Reach will last forever.

Popular Categories

Announcements Arcade Atari Crazy Japanese Stuff DIY DLC DS e3 Funny Stuff Gadgets Gaming Good Ideas Guitar Hero H4xx0ring Halo Hardware Interweb Linux microsoft Music Nintendo PC pictures PS3 psn Retro Gaming Reviews Rock Band Rock Band 2 Rumors screenshots sega Sony Team Teabag! The Orange Box This week in Rock Band Toys Uncategorized Video Video Friday Wii XBLA XBLM Xbox 360 Xbox Live

Team Teabag Twitter

  • RT @Kotaku: PlayStation 3 Destroyed In A Fire Looks Like This http://kotaku.com/5604621//gallery/
  • RT @Dtoid: Trailer shows off batty Guitar Hero 'Quest Mode' http://tinyurl.com/2f4amch. The hell is this crap!? Acti have lost the plot!
  • Music video created in DSi Flipnote Studio - 'Brain Games' by Arman Bohn. Watch it here! http://bit.ly/alrKHK
  • RT @mtvmultiplayer: Apparently StarCraft 2 has been melting video cards! Has anyone else had this problem?
  • RT @majornelson: Trials HD fans: Design and track and you could win -> http://mjr.mn/cUS2X2
  • 2D Worms is making a comeback to the PC this August! More on @Kotaku: http://bit.ly/ct2goY
  • RT @arstechnica: Internet Explorer 9 beta to arrive in September - by @drpizza - http://arst.ch/lu3
  • RT @ConsoleBUZZ: More on R4 High Court Ruling... Illegal to sell ANY flashcart/circumvention device in the UK now. http://bit.ly/afoGy2
  • R4 cartridges illegal in the UK. Thoughts? http://bit.ly/cMvUi4 #R4 #Nintendo #DS
  • A girlfriend simulator? Only in Japan. A girlfriend simulator you play in public, in an arcade? *Definitely* only... http://fb.me/CywCPJwq

« Video: Wholesome Christian Racing Fun… Or Very Bad Trip? Video: Secret CoD4 Training Mission Discovered Thanks To ‘Hack’ »